Dr. Jeckyll, Meet Mr. Hyde

Consistently inconsistent really seems to be the MO of this team. Not sure what they can do about it but here we are struggling to crawl to .500 while beating great teams and tripping over our dicks on those same teams. Having a blast so far. Made it to Tofino after being everywhere in these last 5 days.

Unknown's avatar

About unca_chuck

Lifelong SF 49ers, SF Giants, and Golden State Warriors fan
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

147 Responses to Dr. Jeckyll, Meet Mr. Hyde

  1. snarkk's avatar snarkk says:

    Giants Pen is continually into torture. The 1-2-3 Pen inning apparently isn’t in the Giants planning…

  2. snarkk's avatar snarkk says:

    Now catcher’s interference? Giants appear to be ready to give this away. Come on, just one more out !

  3. blade3colorado's avatar blade3colorado says:

    Fucking easiest challenge ever.

  4. Macdog's avatar Macdog says:

    Finding ways to lose.

  5. blade3colorado's avatar blade3colorado says:

    Figures. Keep playing with fire . . . you get BURNED.

  6. willedav's avatar willedav says:

    Dang. Should have never come to that.

  7. alleykat69's avatar alleykat69 says:

    And their your SF Giants in a nutshell.Blow extra opportunities to add on and in the end Ballgame Walkoff HR!! I’m still sticking with Killian no matter what but not V..

  8. snarkk's avatar snarkk says:

    There it is. No surprise whatever.

    That is what a crap team does. When it does play well enough to win, they can’t close the deal to win.

    In addition to the myriad other problems, this Pen is inexperienced, not confident, not trustworthy. Now NINE under .500. Seriously, Buster better be sketching out and searching out trades. This season should be used to experiment with top minor leaguers. It’s already done for any chance at post season…

  9. djloo27's avatar djloo27 says:

    We need a group vomit…

  10. blade3colorado's avatar blade3colorado says:

    Snarkk’s 9:08pm can’t be emphasized enough . . . You get a situation where Adames walks in the top of the 8th; gets to 2nd on a wild pitch by Ginkel . . . and, what happens?

    Chapman stikes out swinging; Gilbert strikes out swinging; and, Susac strikes out looking.

    Yep, “Giants season in a nutshell.” Pfffttt!

  11. snarkk's avatar snarkk says:

    The Giants would NEVER have taken the risk to send the runner from first in that situation with 2 out in the bottom of the 9th. Yet, the Dbacks did. It put pressure on Susac to make a play on the runner to second, and he blew it, he didn’t make the play, instead he caused catcher’s interference, putting the batter at first, the runner at first onto second, and the rest is history.

    The Giants aren’t athletic enough, not creative enough, to take that kind of risk to win. They are too busy striking out constantly, not making contact, running the bases like a jackass, and laughing with the opposition while standing on base and forgetting how many outs there are …

  12. MrSrtdude's avatar mwrymer says:

    SOOO annoying. I know the decisions aren’t always black n white, but Killian up 0-2 if not for Susac. Not like he gave up a smash hit to get the 2nd runner on. Why is Vitello taking him out there? Re offense? It’s like >3 runs is an impossible hill to climb.

  13. unca_chuck's avatar unca_chuck says:

    Glad I’m missing all this!!

  14. alleykat69's avatar alleykat69 says:

    Oh yeah Charle,I would much rather be hanging out in a Surf village resort area sipping coconut daquris are salted margaritas,checking out bikini 👙 lines then continuing to watch the Giants self destruct every night going beyond even their own capabilities to make them the hardest team in baseball to watch..

  15. snarkk's avatar snarkk says:

    No lineup released yet for today’s day game in Phoenix. Eldridge is so far down the bench, Vitello has sent out a search party…

  16. snarkk's avatar snarkk says:

    Lineup in.

    Eldridge apparently has been found.

    Merrill Kelley hasn’t been great so far this year, but against the Giants, that’s meaningless.

    Outfield is Schmitt, Gilbert, Brennan. Schmitt has his bat bona fides, but he’s a rookie glove out there. The other two, whatever, they’re in there for the lefty/righty thing. IMO that has the look of minor league outfield.

    They need to avoid the sweep or its 10 games under .500. In my book, that’s the Rubicon for breaking on through from life support to the other side…

    • willedav's avatar willedav says:

      Eldridge gets 3 starts a week so he’s hardly in milk carton status. 2 singles he got the other day was most he’s done so far. I’d like to see him do more with bat in his hands than wave at breaking balls away from him in the dirt. Make Giants play you by smoking a few hits out there.
      Susac sure did and he’s a Rule 5 guy A’s let go for nothing.

      • snarkk's avatar snarkk says:

        I warned that the Giants would bring him up only to sit him. He’s appeared in 9 of 16 games since being called up. Only 28 ABs. He should have nearly 50. Giants have touted this kid as the savior of the organization for quite a while, now they treat him like a utility guy they just picked up from Cleveland. They played him against all-world RHPs Ohtani and Yamamoto, then sat him against the A’s RHP Severino who the Giants crushed. All nonsensical, inconsistent. If there’s a plan, what is it?

        He has played only one game of defense at 1B, the position he has been “learning” at both AA and AAA. The universal opinion across all media talking about this — you can see it all over the internet — is that he should either play much more, or go back down to SAC and work — play every day, consistent ABs and 1b glove work. Do you think playing here and there in SF in between mostly riding pine is the best thing to help him stop “waving” at breaking balls as you describe it? How’s he going to learn how to hit if he sits on the bench and hits against a machine under the stands at Oracle? The Giants are dead wrong if they keep doing this to him, it will wreck him just like they’ve wrecked other farmhands. If he’s got a hole in that big swing down low, and it looks like he does, then send him to Sac to fix it, not hold him in limbo fer Kreissakes.

        John Shea, the eminent baseball writer following the Giants for 40+ years, said on KNBR today that this handling of Eldridge makes no sense to him. I’ll go with his opinion…

  17. blade3colorado's avatar blade3colorado says:

    AK, I watch because I am a masochist for pain. Seriously though, I watch for the “shit and giggles” the Giants provide nightly. No, that isn’t an anomaly, as I love the Giants.

    However, you can ask Loo and Mac how well the NY Mets drew when they were the laughing stock of the MLB back in the 1960s. During their first two seasons at the crumbling old Polo Grounds, the Mets drew over 900,000 and 1 million fans respectively despite losing 120 and 111 games, OUTDRAWING THE NY YANKEES!

    The real explosion occurred when they moved into the new, Shea Stadium, where attendance almost doubled. All of them must have been masochists\want a shitload of yuk yuks, like myself; along with everyone that goes to Oracle or watches them on TV. In that regard, the Giants do not disappoint.

  18. Winder's avatar Winder says:

    Reading the Giants this year is kinda like reading the 49ers run game without McCaffrey. You just know it’s not gonna work. I thought we were going to lose it when Winn was pitching but we were just delaying the inevitable. Whatever, sloppy play seems to now be Giants baseball. So very sad.

  19. willedav's avatar willedav says:

    There you go, off the CF wall.

  20. willedav's avatar willedav says:

    As for Eldridge I’ll go with Earl Weaver, who knew hell of a lot more than shea or anyone else. What he said was he had no problem playing a rookie 2-3 times a week, and that if he could help the team win a couple games a week it would be a good thing–for the team, not just for rookie himself. Which is the single most important job of the manager– win games.

    “I don’t necessarily think that it’s bad to have rookies on the bench. A young player may be able to play twice a week and help you win two games….if a kid is sitting and rotting on the bench you have to send him back to the minors. But…someone has to give him a chance in the majors. That doesn’t necessarily mean playing him every day.”

    bottom line it’s up to Eldridge to do what Susac did and force your way in there over someone else.

    • snarkk's avatar snarkk says:

      Comparing Susac situation to Eldridge is ludicrous. Bailey was an automatic out, and his framing value had fallen, so playing a catcher who was decent at defense with any kind of a bat was a no brainer. Eldridge has been on the hype radar for a couple of years.

      His double this afternoon just shows you gotta play this kid, whether its in SF or Sac. Wasting time on any bench is complete malpractice of development. Earl Weaver, RIP, can pound sand with 50 year old advice on how to develop rookies in the 2020s…

      • blade3colorado's avatar blade3colorado says:

        What I have been saying . . . If you’re not going to play him every day, particularly with this putrid LU and THE SEASON GOING NO WHERE, you’re: 1. Not really interested in seeing him develop: and/or, 2. Incompetent.

        Again, this season is in the shitter. No way, no how, they are going to realistically going to compete with other legit Wild Card teams, and particularly with the Division and WS favorite, Bums. This season is all about separating the wheat from the chaff. That’s it.

      • willedav's avatar willedav says:

        Blade/snarkk Vitello is trying to win games and put best lineup out there–and if he continues to lose games at rate they’re going he’s not long for the job. It’s not his job to develop players, that’s on coaching staff and player himself when he’s not in there. I stand by what I said–Susac ran Bailey out of town and forced Giants hands by hitting his way into the lineup. Love to see Eldridge do the same but I am not handing every day job to 21 year old kid few years out of HS, who struck out a lot everywhere he’s been. He doesn’t deserve it, yet.

        I still think it’s perfectly fine to play Eldridge half the games/3 times a week until he starts hitting better with more power.The Giants are overloaded with 6 IFs for 5 spots, 4 plus DH. Like it or not, and I get fans are pissed at team, sitting Chapman and Adames, let alone Devers, once a week to collect their thoughts. The 2 games over weekend where Giants hit ball like crazy, won twice and scored ton of runs vs. A’s, Eldridge wasn’t a part of it. so they didn’t need him.

Super Bowl Win, Purdy Please